The chart above illustrates the average auto insurance premiums across Canada. Typically the province of Ontario is characterized by the highest auto insurance rates. Quebec, as a rule, has more affordable car insurance premiums since the health part of the insurance (e.g. bodily injuries) is covered by the government. Not all provinces allow customers to choose from a variety of insurers. Three provinces have crown companies being the only source of vehicle insurance:


Before shopping for the best car insurance rates, it is a good idea to do a little bit of homework first. Insurance companies know their products, and it can be easy to become tricked into signing on to a policy with hidden downfalls that the average consumer will not think to ask about. Insurance brokers are not obligated to quote the cheapest rate, so you should ask what those rates are and what the policies entail. Another aspect many shoppers forget to consider is cancellation fees. Before signing anything, you should read the fine print. Every policy has different stipulations, and you should understand what those are or risk being dropped if you get a couple of tickets.
When it comes to auto insurance, especially auto insurance in Ontario, many people question whether or not there’s really a way to save money on it. There is! While there are many ways to save, none are more effective than shopping around. How can we be so sure? Well, on average, InsuranceHotline.com shoppers save $450* after comparing car insurance quotes on our site. And, all it takes is a few minutes to compare quotes from our network of over 30 insurance providers. 
What the above facts help illustrate is that, quite simply, Toronto is a big, busy city with lots of cars on the road. This translates to lots of driving and lots of traffic congestion, which can lead to accidents - especially multi-vehicle accidents. Factor in pedestrians, cyclists, and public transportation (TTC), and there is no shortage of things that drivers need to pay attention to when behind the wheel.
For those placed in this unfortunate situation, there is an insurance pool called the Facility Association, which serves as a last resort for those unable to convince an auto insurance service provider to insure their vehicle with an appropriate policy. However, a checkered driving history and the high risk associated with unsafe driving practices will still work against candidates as far as auto insurance costs go.

Young drivers, those under 25 years of age, can expect to pay considerably more for auto insurance in Ontario. The younger the driver the higher the premiums tend to be. Statistics show that young drivers are much more likely to have traffic violations and be involved in car collisions, probably partly due to lack of driving experience. Auto Insurance companies in Ontario take that into account and as a result charge young drivers much higher premiums to compensate for the risk of insuring them.


Comprehensive: With this option, you’re covered for any threat or danger other than collision, including theft*, damage or loss caused by vandalism, projectiles, and falling or flying objects such as stones kicked up by a truck in front of you. The important thing to remember is that this coverage applies to your vehicle only, not you or your passengers.
Our guarantee is that within 30 minutes of answering your call, a claims representative will start the claims process, and will have the ability to take charge of the situation and arrange emergency support if required (the "Guarantee"). This applies only in respect of new loss or damage not previously reported to us in respect of a valid belairdirect personal auto or home policy (the "Policy"). The support offered by our claims representatives depends on your insurance coverage and when we receive your call. To activate the Guarantee, the policyholder must call and speak to a claims representative. No other form of communication is permitted to activate the Guarantee. The Guarantee is not valid if our operations are impacted by a system failure or catastrophic situation occurring in Canada at the time of your call, such as: earthquake, blackout, hailstorm, forest fire, flood, act of terrorism, war or other major natural disaster, or political unrest. If we are not able to live up to the Guarantee we will write you a cheque in the amount of the annual premium of your home or auto insurance Policy relating to the claim to a maximum of $1,000. Your coverage will not be affected as a direct result of this payment. Terms and conditions of this Guarantee may change without notice.
Some employers will offer their employees savings or discounts to employees on their car insurance if you go through them, similar to professional associations and their members. The same tips apply for this as with associations: ask the organization how the insurance benefits work, and make sure to still shop around in case you can find a better deal elsewhere.

If you're in an accident or fender bender, you may think that a run-of-the-mill cheap car insurance policy covers you well enough to fix your car. But what if it doesn't? While saving a little money on your monthly bill may work in the short term, after an accident your car may not be covered, leaving you to pay for car repairs out of your own pocket. What initially seemed like a quick way to save will end up costing you more money.


We want to hear from you and encourage a lively discussion among our users. Please help us keep our site clean and safe by following our posting guidelines, and avoid disclosing personal or sensitive information such as bank account or phone numbers. Any comments posted under NerdWallet's official account are not reviewed or endorsed by representatives of financial institutions affiliated with the reviewed products, unless explicitly stated otherwise.
Many Ontario drivers have additional third party insurance coverage. This is a wise move since the provincial requirement is only for $200,000. Settlements from serious accidents often exceed this amount. Any amount in excess of insurance coverage remains the responsibility of the driver. To guard against serious financial strain, it’s common to add liability coverage to $500,000 and beyond.
Other insurance conditions may arise depending on the type of vehicle, its use, and any customizations or modifications made to the vehicle. For example, if you have altered your vehicle to enhance its performance or appearance, most insurance companies would need to assess the vehicle to determine if they could insure it. If you plan on modifying your vehicle, call us first! We will let you know if the changes you plan on making could have an impact on your policy.
×