You might think that car insurance quotes for the same driver/car would be similar across all providers, but every auto insurance company has its own costs to cover, based on data about all of their existing users/claims. In fact, an insurance rate calculation has many subtle complexities to it and multiple factors contribute to the final rate you receive. Based on the information you provide for your driving profile a car insurance company will categorize your risk potential and calculate a personalized rate. Unfortunately, some factors are out of your control, but there are still a few that you are 100% in the driver’s seat for, so being in the know could save you money on your auto insurance policy. Here are seven factors that auto insurance companies will consider before offering you a personalized car insurance rate.


Raising the deductible limits on collision and comprehensive coverage lowers monthly insurance premiums. By taking on more financial responsibility in the case of an accident, a driver lowers day to day costs. A driver must be ready, however, to absorb these costs if an accident occurs. Note that in some cases where a driver is not at fault, other insurance provisions or companies may cover some or all deductible amounts. Check with your agent or broker to determine what applies to your specific policy.
Credit Cards Savings: Based on avoidance of unnecessary card fees and correctly chosen insurance protection via a credit card, including $280 in rental car insurance (renting a car for 2 weeks per year), $70 in card fee (fee difference for cards with similar insurance protection), $70 in travel medical insurance for one person for three weeks, and $80 for extended warranty for one electronic device purchased during a year.

Not all collisions affect your insurance rates, but crashes where you’re deemed at fault will drive up your premiums. Insurers care about your three-year driving record, because that’s how long convictions stay on your driving record. A single speeding ticket may not have a huge impact on your premiums, but repeated infractions could cost you – and serious driving crimes that result in court convictions can really hit hard.
Parts of your auto insurance policy may have deductibles. A deductible is the portion of an insurance claim you agree to pay. Your car insurance provider covers the remaining cost. Your deductibles play a part in how your rates are calculated. Depending on how much financial responsibility you take on in the event of a claim, your auto insurance rates will reflect your commitment. Take on more responsibility (i.e. increase your deductibles) and your rates will lower, take on less responsibility (i.e. decrease your deductibles) and your auto insurance premiums will increase.
Since most people choose one of these large insurers, NerdWallet compared quotes from the five largest auto companies in ZIP codes across the country. Rates are for policies that include minimum coverage required in each state, plus collision and comprehensive coverage. Our “good driver” profile is a 30-year-old with no moving violations and credit in the “good” tier. Use the tabs to see rates for drivers with credit in the “poor” tier and those with one at-fault accident as reported to the insurer.
Because you indicated you occasionally have non-family members as passengers in your car, we recommend Additional Third Party Liability for you. The more passengers you have in your car, the more damages you can be liable for in the event of an accident – not only are non-family members not covered by most standard insurance, they are also more likely to file law suits.

Would consumers consider buying auto insurance from Google? Although it’s a household name in Internet search, this would be its first time in the auto insurance space. According to a study by Accenture insurance research, two-thirds (67 percent) of U.S. consumers would consider purchasing insurance from sources other than insurance companies, and 23 percent would consider buying online from service providers like Google and Amazon.
Our guarantee is that within 30 minutes of answering your call, a claims representative will start the claims process, and will have the ability to take charge of the situation and arrange emergency support if required (the "Guarantee"). This applies only in respect of new loss or damage not previously reported to us in respect of a valid belairdirect personal auto or home policy (the "Policy"). The support offered by our claims representatives depends on your insurance coverage and when we receive your call. To activate the Guarantee, the policyholder must call and speak to a claims representative. No other form of communication is permitted to activate the Guarantee. The Guarantee is not valid if our operations are impacted by a system failure or catastrophic situation occurring in Canada at the time of your call, such as: earthquake, blackout, hailstorm, forest fire, flood, act of terrorism, war or other major natural disaster, or political unrest. If we are not able to live up to the Guarantee we will write you a cheque in the amount of the annual premium of your home or auto insurance Policy relating to the claim to a maximum of $1,000. Your coverage will not be affected as a direct result of this payment. Terms and conditions of this Guarantee may change without notice.
A couple of at-fault collisions, a few traffic violations or an impaired driving conviction is all it takes to get a high risk driver designation from an auto insurance company in Ontario. That sets you up for high auto insurance premiums for several years or perhaps worse, an outright cancellation or non-renewal of your existing Ontario auto insurance policy.
As a resident of Ontario, you will automatically qualify for a 5% discount on eligible coverage* if you complete a car insurance quote using our online quoter right now. The personalized quote will also be emailed to you so you can refer to it at any time. If you want to save up to an additional 25% on your premium, download and use the TD MyAdvantage app!
×