We want to hear from you and encourage a lively discussion among our users. Please help us keep our site clean and safe by following our posting guidelines, and avoid disclosing personal or sensitive information such as bank account or phone numbers. Any comments posted under NerdWallet's official account are not reviewed or endorsed by representatives of financial institutions affiliated with the reviewed products, unless explicitly stated otherwise.
Although rural backroads and small-towns in Ontario do have their own unique hazards, owning and driving a car in an urban area, like Toronto or Ottawa, carries significantly higher risks for everything from traffic accidents to theft to minor fender benders. Due to the higher risk associated with cars in the city, car insurance is generally more expensive in city centres.
Getting started is easy, and all it takes it filling out one form. From there, we do the legwork and get rates from over 50 providers in Ontario. We show you quotes directly from the insurers, so there’s no need to go to multiple websites and fill out the same form over and over again. What’s more, we show you the best rates available, making it easy for you to pick the coverage and price you like best for your needs.
For the most part, cars that are considered compact, mid-size and full size are the most common vehicles quoted from Ontario drivers. The Honda CR-V and Ford Escape are the only crossovers that made it on this list. Although the Dodge Grand Caravan didn’t make the list of top 10, it was number 11, making it a top choice for Ontario drivers that require a family-friendly vehicle.
As of January 1st 2016, the Ontario government passed a law mandating that insurance companies give drivers a discount on their insurance if they buy and install winter tires on their cars for the winter months. The discount is usually around 5% of your collision coverage, or $72 per vehicle per year, but you will not necessarily get this discount immediately. Some companies make you wait until your policy renews, so make sure you call your insurer to find out how they handle it.
While vacationing in California, you have a serious accident for which you are held responsible, leaving the other driver seriously injured. The other driver decides to sue, which results in a judgment against you for the damages to the other driver's vehicle, medical expenses and loss of revenue. The settlement is expensive, but your Additional Third Party Liability helps to cover it.
National advertising powered by Mediative.com. Yellow PagesTM, Walking Fingers & DesignTM, YP.caTM, Find. & DesignTM, YellowPages.caTM, Canada411TM and YP ShopwiseTM are trademarks of Yellow Pages Digital & Media Solutions Limited in Canada. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners. Copyright © 2018 Yellow Pages Digital & Media Solutions Limited. All Rights Reserved. 5.32.0.0 (rev 20181003.1434)

National advertising powered by Mediative.com. Yellow PagesTM, Walking Fingers & DesignTM, YP.caTM, Find. & DesignTM, YellowPages.caTM, Canada411TM and YP ShopwiseTM are trademarks of Yellow Pages Digital & Media Solutions Limited in Canada. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners. Copyright © 2018 Yellow Pages Digital & Media Solutions Limited. All Rights Reserved. 5.32.0.0 (rev 20181003.1434)
If you’ve chosen to include Collision coverage, Comprehensive coverage, or both on your auto insurance policy, the broker or agent you speak with when discussing your insurance needs will ask you about deductibles. Specifically, you’ll be asked how much you’d like your deductibles to be. Give this question some thought before answering because you’ll want to pick a deductible that fits your budget and will not cause financial stress should you need to submit a claim. While it’s true, your car insurance premiums will be lower with a higher deductible, your deductible needs to align with your personal finances. In general, the most common choices for deductibles are $1,000 or $500; however, there may be other deductible options available to you that may better fit your needs.
Each quarter, insurers can apply to have their rates increased or decreased. The Financial Services Commission of Ontario (FSCO), which oversees insurance regulation in the province, approves or denies these requests. Most of the time, insurers request rate increases due to changes in a particular coverage. For example, an insurer experiencing an increased prevalence in payouts resulting from car accidents might apply to have rates increased to help offset the costs of increased claims.
It is often possible for those seeking cheap car insurance to bundle their service and get an additional discount on other policies such as home insurance. For example, if you have multiple drivers living in a home you own, rather than having separate car insurance policies and a separate home insurance policy, you can often get everything covered in one policy at a significantly discounted rate. Best of all, you can save time when it comes time to pay bills as you will only have to make a single payment.
Rental car insurance: A rental car insurance rider is a good product to buy as additional protection with your auto insurance policy. It is an add-on that extends your existing individual car insurance to a rental vehicle. It costs around $20-$30/year. If you decide to get rental car insurance in a rental location, it will cost you $15-$20/day. See the difference?

Cutting back car insurance coverage to meet the provincial minimum requirement is only an option for a few drivers who are able and willing to take on the financial costs of repairing or replacing a vehicle after an accident. The standard provincial policy does not include collision or comprehensive insurance provisions. However, drivers financing car purchases may find that lenders have insurance requirements.
Perhaps the worst kept secret or simply the best advice to finding cheap car insurance in Toronto is something you’ve heard over and over again: shop around and compare. Comparing car insurance quotes from multiple companies is one of the the best options available to save money and a simple, convenient way to accomplish this is by going online to do your research. In fact, some car insurance companies in Toronto will give you a 5 to 10 percent discount just by filling out your information and signing up for a policy online because you are saving them from using costlier resources. We’ll insert a shameless plug here and inform you that Rates.ca simplifies the online research process with a proven customized comparison tool that helps you obtain among the lowest car insurance policies on the market.
As a resident of Ontario, you will automatically qualify for a 5% discount on eligible coverage* if you complete a car insurance quote using our online quoter right now. The personalized quote will also be emailed to you so you can refer to it at any time. If you want to save up to an additional 25% on your premium, download and use the TD MyAdvantage app!
×