There are alternatives for those who are motivated. The first step is to start shopping for competitive auto insurance rates in Ontario. Using a superior comparison site such as Rates.ca will help any driver find a auto insurance provider in Ontario for a better price than expected. All auto insurance agents and brokers in Ontario do not necessarily operate the same and will arrive at their own assessment, which often means drivers will be presented with a range of insurance options with different cost structures. Even though drivers still fall in the high risk category, it represents an opportunity to start improving your driving record. It’s best to discuss your accidents, infractions and convictions openly and to find out how long a time period they will count against you, as this varies from province to province.
By entering my driver's licence number, I authorize CAA Insurance to retrieve prior insurance history for myself to provide me with a faster, more accurate quote. I understand this information will be handled in accordance with the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use of CAA Insurance.By clicking on "Get Started" you agree to the CAA Insurance Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
If you’ve spent time comparing car insurance quotes online, you have a pretty good idea of all the different options available to you. So what makes us different? Well, it’s about more than car insurance rates. We built a strong network of advisors in Ontario and across the country who are always available to bring you excellent service. Add more than 70 years of experience as a co-operative, and you can feel confident that we know exactly how to make sure our members and communities come first.
You can save a bit of money by paying for your insurance once per year rather than once per month. This helps the insurance company save on the administrative costs of billing you every month and a lot of the time they will pass the cost savings on to you. It means you will have to pay a larger amount all at once, but in the long run it can help you save as long as you have that money up front.
While Toronto politicians have made efforts to encourage the use of transit and bike lanes, the truth is that more and more residents are choosing to drive. If you are one of them, it is crucial that you have a quality car insurance policy that will cover you when the unexpected occurs. By following these guidelines, you can get the best coverage for your money.
Young drivers, those under 25 years of age, can expect to pay considerably more for auto insurance in Ontario. The younger the driver the higher the premiums tend to be. Statistics show that young drivers are much more likely to have traffic violations and be involved in car collisions, probably partly due to lack of driving experience. Auto Insurance companies in Ontario take that into account and as a result charge young drivers much higher premiums to compensate for the risk of insuring them.
For the most part, cars that are considered compact, mid-size and full size are the most common vehicles quoted from Ontario drivers. The Honda CR-V and Ford Escape are the only crossovers that made it on this list. Although the Dodge Grand Caravan didn’t make the list of top 10, it was number 11, making it a top choice for Ontario drivers that require a family-friendly vehicle.
You might think that car insurance quotes for the same driver/car would be similar across all providers, but every auto insurance company has its own costs to cover, based on data about all of their existing users/claims. In fact, an insurance rate calculation has many subtle complexities to it and multiple factors contribute to the final rate you receive. Based on the information you provide for your driving profile a car insurance company will categorize your risk potential and calculate a personalized rate. Unfortunately, some factors are out of your control, but there are still a few that you are 100% in the driver’s seat for, so being in the know could save you money on your auto insurance policy. Here are seven factors that auto insurance companies will consider before offering you a personalized car insurance rate.

Since most people choose one of these large insurers, NerdWallet compared quotes from the five largest auto companies in ZIP codes across the country. Rates are for policies that include minimum coverage required in each state, plus collision and comprehensive coverage. Our “good driver” profile is a 30-year-old with no moving violations and credit in the “good” tier. Use the tabs to see rates for drivers with credit in the “poor” tier and those with one at-fault accident as reported to the insurer.
Overall, men are considered riskier drivers. According to Statistics Canada, men are involved in more than twice as many deadly collisions than women. Drivers under the age of 25, particularly single males, have statistically higher collision rates, and therefore pay higher rates. Insurance is all about assessing risk based on data, so companies consider a number of general factors, including time spent driving, type of vehicle, number of accidents, and general driving behaviours. In some cases, being married – especially if your partner has a good driving record – can reduce your rates.

The chart above illustrates the average auto insurance premiums across Canada. Typically the province of Ontario is characterized by the highest auto insurance rates. Quebec, as a rule, has more affordable car insurance premiums since the health part of the insurance (e.g. bodily injuries) is covered by the government. Not all provinces allow customers to choose from a variety of insurers. Three provinces have crown companies being the only source of vehicle insurance:
Would you like to receive rewards for driving well? Participate in our innovative en-route Auto Program and you could see your insurance discounted by up to 25%*! We send you a wireless device† – at no cost – that's easy to install under your steering column. Once in place, it will track your driving, and you will be rewarded for travelling less, avoiding late-night journeys and braking/accelerating safely. You can rest easy knowing that the entire program is free, and that your premium cannot increase as a result – the data is only used to calculate your discount. Sign up today and save 5% instantly!

Before you commit to anything, make sure you shop around. It's best to compare car insurance quotes offered by insurers and brokers (it's best to get a minimum of 3 quotes). You should make your final purchase with the company or person who provided you with the best service and a competitive rate. The insurance representative should take the time to answer all of your questions and make you feel comfortable about the purchase.
The chart above illustrates the average auto insurance premiums across Canada. Typically the province of Ontario is characterized by the highest auto insurance rates. Quebec, as a rule, has more affordable car insurance premiums since the health part of the insurance (e.g. bodily injuries) is covered by the government. Not all provinces allow customers to choose from a variety of insurers. Three provinces have crown companies being the only source of vehicle insurance:
Certain conditions, limitations and exclusions apply to all our offers. Not everyone will qualify for a phone or online quote. Insurance products provided by Trafalgar Insurance Company of Canada. Services provided by belairdirect Agency Inc. ®belairdirect. and ®Little Knight Design are registered trademarks of Belair Insurance Company Inc. used under licence. © 2018 Belair Insurance Company Inc., content used under licence by belairdirect Agency Inc. All rights reserved.
Not all collisions affect your insurance rates, but crashes where you’re deemed at fault will drive up your premiums. Insurers care about your three-year driving record, because that’s how long convictions stay on your driving record. A single speeding ticket may not have a huge impact on your premiums, but repeated infractions could cost you – and serious driving crimes that result in court convictions can really hit hard.
Limited waiver of depreciation: This coverage protects against the loss of value or depreciation of a new car if, as a result of an accident, your car is beyond repair and must be replaced. This coverage is only available during the first two years of a vehicle lease or ownership. You could receive an amount up to the price you paid for the vehicle or the manufacturer’s suggested price. You can only add this endorsement if you have insured your vehicle with Collision and Comprehensive coverage, Collision and Specified Perils coverage or All Perils coverage.
These policies are unique because ride-share drivers are in a unique position. You use your personal vehicle for business purposes, blurring the lines between commercial and personal auto insurance coverage. Ride-share insurance was created to fill that gap. To learn more about insurance for Uber drivers and similar ride-sharing programs, visit our ride-share insurance page here. 
Keep in mind that the minimum car insurance coverage required is determined by the Government of Ontario and may vary in comparison to Alberta, New Brunswick, Newfoundland/Labrador, Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Island, and Quebec. In addition, premiums can vary depending on the area in which you reside, typically being higher in major urban centres, such as Toronto.
×