Since most people choose one of these large insurers, NerdWallet compared quotes from the five largest auto companies in ZIP codes across the country. Rates are for policies that include minimum coverage required in each state, plus collision and comprehensive coverage. Our “good driver” profile is a 30-year-old with no moving violations and credit in the “good” tier. Use the tabs to see rates for drivers with credit in the “poor” tier and those with one at-fault accident as reported to the insurer.
Here's what happens in case of a covered accident: First, you report a claim — online, or through your agent. If there's damage to your vehicle, you can choose your own repair shop or one of our preferred auto shops, which provide great repairs and guaranteed completion dates. Then, subject to the terms and conditions of your auto insurance policy, we pay for the damages. Our claim specialists help find repair facilities in your area, keep you updated on work being done, and process your claim quickly and efficiently.

Mortgage Savings: Based on the present value of monthly savings over the mortgage term (3-years). The monthly savings is the difference in monthly payments between the lowest and third lowest mortgage rates from major Canadian lenders as of April 24, 2012. These rates are for a 3-Year closed mortgage for $350,000, with an amortization period of 25 years, in the province of Ontario, for a borrower with a good credit rating.
If you’ve spent time comparing car insurance quotes online, you have a pretty good idea of all the different options available to you. So what makes us different? Well, it’s about more than car insurance rates. We built a strong network of advisors in Ontario and across the country who are always available to bring you excellent service. Add more than 70 years of experience as a co-operative, and you can feel confident that we know exactly how to make sure our members and communities come first.
No consideration of your driving experience: Some insurers will accept the fact that you can buy car insurance (with a newly received Canadian driving licence) but will treat you like somebody who has just got a driving licence and has no driving experience. If you are a young driver in Ontario, your rates can reach $250-$350 per month – not a very attractive scenario!

Not all collisions affect your insurance rates, but crashes where you’re deemed at fault will drive up your premiums. Insurers care about your three-year driving record, because that’s how long convictions stay on your driving record. A single speeding ticket may not have a huge impact on your premiums, but repeated infractions could cost you – and serious driving crimes that result in court convictions can really hit hard.


Preferred Vendor Program: Preferred Vendors offer the highest-quality workmanship. When you choose a Preferred Vendor for your repairs, the quality of workmanship is monitored and the bill is settled directly with the repair shop, giving you a hassle-free claims experience. Plus, collision repairs made by a Preferred Vendor are guaranteed for life.1
Overall, men are considered riskier drivers. According to Statistics Canada, men are involved in more than twice as many deadly collisions than women. Drivers under the age of 25, particularly single males, have statistically higher collision rates, and therefore pay higher rates. Insurance is all about assessing risk based on data, so companies consider a number of general factors, including time spent driving, type of vehicle, number of accidents, and general driving behaviours. In some cases, being married – especially if your partner has a good driving record – can reduce your rates.
Those that will continue your driving record: Some companies will consider your previous experience and will offer you a rate based on how long you have been driving, no matter where you got your on-road experience. Check with a broker to see which companies consider previous out-of-Canada experience so you can reduce your chances of a denial and increase your chances of getting the best possible rate.
Mortgage Savings: Based on the present value of monthly savings over the mortgage term (3-years). The monthly savings is the difference in monthly payments between the lowest and third lowest mortgage rates from major Canadian lenders as of April 24, 2012. These rates are for a 3-Year closed mortgage for $350,000, with an amortization period of 25 years, in the province of Ontario, for a borrower with a good credit rating.
Among the things insurance companies don’t take into account are: employment history, bankruptcy, your housing situation and history, or your net worth. In Ontario and Newfoundland and Labrador, insurers also cannot take your credit score into account when assessing your premiums – but in Nova Scotia they can; in Alberta, they need your permission. Car colour also doesn’t affect rates – it is a widely-believed myth that owners of red cars pay more – they don’t.
We're proud of our long history. Over 70 years of providing Canadians with reliable insurance and accurate car insurance quotes in Ontario. Along with our insurance, you can also expect to receive customer service that treats you like an individual, which means you won't find pre-packaged, one-size-fits-all coverage when researching our many and varied solutions. Contact The Co-operators today to learn more. Select the city nearest you from the list.

Usage-based insurance (UBI) is another new technology that is also becoming more popular where you pay your insurance based on when and how you drive. You install the necessary tracking device on your car and it, along with a GPS, monitors your driving behaviour. The data is examined when your policy is up for renewal, and usually looks at the following:
To make sure you get all the available discounts, we apply savings automatically during your car insurance quote. Keep in mind, a lot goes into determining your price, including the vehicle you drive, where you live, how much you drive, and your driving record — as well as coverages, deductibles, and limits. In some provinces your age, gender, and marital status may be factors. Your agent can help you decide how best to balance coverage and price and confirm you're getting all the discounts you're eligible for.
×