Canada’s 9th largest city by population, Brampton sees congestion, poor road conditions, long commutes and a high incidence rate for accidents. Insurance claims costs in the area, also much higher than other parts of the province, may stem from an active insurance fraud network using facilities in the area. Auto insurance fraud practices stem from staged accidents, exploitative towing operators, over-billing repair facilities and unscrupulous medical and rehabilitation clinics. The cost per accident in Brampton is high. All local drivers share the cost to service the area.
A couple of at-fault collisions, a few traffic violations or an impaired driving conviction is all it takes to get a high risk driver designation from an auto insurance company in Ontario. That sets you up for high auto insurance premiums for several years or perhaps worse, an outright cancellation or non-renewal of your existing Ontario auto insurance policy.
Disclaimer: NerdWallet strives to keep its information accurate and up to date. This information may be different than what you see when you visit a financial institution, service provider or specific product’s site. All financial products, shopping products and services are presented without warranty. When evaluating offers, please review the financial institution’s Terms and Conditions. Pre-qualified offers are not binding. If you find discrepancies with your credit score or information from your credit report, please contact TransUnion® directly.
As for best place to shop for insurance, I always try Kanetix before I buy any car (new or used), and every year before my insurance is up for renewal. For the past 4 years TD has been the cheapest for me, but that doesn't mean it'll be cheaper for everyone. It depends on how many cars/drivers you insure, if you insure property, and of course it depends on your record, experience, etc.
Among the things insurance companies don’t take into account are: employment history, bankruptcy, your housing situation and history, or your net worth. In Ontario and Newfoundland and Labrador, insurers also cannot take your credit score into account when assessing your premiums – but in Nova Scotia they can; in Alberta, they need your permission. Car colour also doesn’t affect rates – it is a widely-believed myth that owners of red cars pay more – they don’t.

If you have a clean driving record, you qualify for a good driver discount – up to 25% off your premium with programs like Intact’s My Driver Discount. All you need to do is plug a device into your vehicle’s Onboard Diagnostic (OBD) port to track your good driving habits. Information relayed by the device is never used to penalize you – only reward you. We also have other programs available which offer good driving discounts without the use of a device.

When comparing prices, make sure you know exactly what’s included in your policy. Carefully check the coverage, deductibles and liability limits. While it’s always nice to save money, a lower-priced policy might cost you more in the long run if you discover later that it doesn’t have enough coverage for you and your family. Look for the insurance coverage that best matches your needs, not necessarily the one that costs less.
The chart above illustrates the average auto insurance premiums across Canada. Typically the province of Ontario is characterized by the highest auto insurance rates. Quebec, as a rule, has more affordable car insurance premiums since the health part of the insurance (e.g. bodily injuries) is covered by the government. Not all provinces allow customers to choose from a variety of insurers. Three provinces have crown companies being the only source of vehicle insurance:
There are alternatives for those who are motivated. The first step is to start shopping for competitive auto insurance rates in Ontario. Using a superior comparison site such as Rates.ca will help any driver find a auto insurance provider in Ontario for a better price than expected. All auto insurance agents and brokers in Ontario do not necessarily operate the same and will arrive at their own assessment, which often means drivers will be presented with a range of insurance options with different cost structures. Even though drivers still fall in the high risk category, it represents an opportunity to start improving your driving record. It’s best to discuss your accidents, infractions and convictions openly and to find out how long a time period they will count against you, as this varies from province to province.
To follow that excellent advice, we’ll continue with another common tip: increase your deductible. It’s not uncommon for those who increase their deductible from $350 to $500 to save 10 to 20 percent on their annual car insurance cost, and possibly a lot more if you bump up the deductible to $1,000. As you discuss this with your car insurance broker or representative in Toronto, why not ask about how combining policies, or bundling insurance packages, can save you money. It’s quite reasonable to expect a 15 percent discount by having one company providing both your home and car insurance requirements. Also, if you have the means, paying your annual premium in one lump sum is another method to lower insurance costs.
Raising the deductible limits on collision and comprehensive coverage lowers monthly insurance premiums. By taking on more financial responsibility in the case of an accident, a driver lowers day to day costs. A driver must be ready, however, to absorb these costs if an accident occurs. Note that in some cases where a driver is not at fault, other insurance provisions or companies may cover some or all deductible amounts. Check with your agent or broker to determine what applies to your specific policy.
®belairdirect. and ®Little Knight Design are registered trademarks of Belair Insurance Company Inc. Certain conditions, limitations and exclusions apply to all our offers. Offers may change without notice. Not everyone will qualify for a phone or online quote. Insurance products may be underwritten by either Belair Insurance Company Inc. Services provided by belairdirect Agency Inc. ©2018 Belair Insurance Company Inc. All rights reserved.
Credit Cards Savings: Based on avoidance of unnecessary card fees and correctly chosen insurance protection via a credit card, including $280 in rental car insurance (renting a car for 2 weeks per year), $70 in card fee (fee difference for cards with similar insurance protection), $70 in travel medical insurance for one person for three weeks, and $80 for extended warranty for one electronic device purchased during a year.
While vacationing in California, you have a serious accident for which you are held responsible, leaving the other driver seriously injured. The other driver decides to sue, which results in a judgment against you for the damages to the other driver's vehicle, medical expenses and loss of revenue. The settlement is expensive, but your Additional Third Party Liability helps to cover it.
If either of you are university graduates, you'll likely get a discount through TD. When you talk to them, ask them for their discounts or tell them of any school you go to, association you belong to or employer you work for. One might have a discount with them. The next time you look for car insurance, try Kanetix's search engine. They generate top insurance quotes. I do it once a year then go the top five places and use their specific search for quotes. Takes like an hour each year, but it's saved me hundreds.

Become an occasional driver under your parents’ policy – Consider being an occasional driver before getting your own car and becoming a primary driver. Occasional drivers pay significantly less for auto insurance. You can build up driving experience while being an occasional driver and end up paying less for auto insurance once you become a primary driver down the road.

Each quarter, insurers can apply to have their rates increased or decreased. The Financial Services Commission of Ontario (FSCO), which oversees insurance regulation in the province, approves or denies these requests. Most of the time, insurers request rate increases due to changes in a particular coverage. For example, an insurer experiencing an increased prevalence in payouts resulting from car accidents might apply to have rates increased to help offset the costs of increased claims.
Cutting back car insurance coverage to meet the provincial minimum requirement is only an option for a few drivers who are able and willing to take on the financial costs of repairing or replacing a vehicle after an accident. The standard provincial policy does not include collision or comprehensive insurance provisions. However, drivers financing car purchases may find that lenders have insurance requirements.
You can apply for RBC Simplified Disability Insurance if you’re age 18 to 55, you’re a Canadian citizen or permanent resident/landed immigrant, and you work at least 30 hours per week. It’s ideal for self-employed individuals, contract workers, subcontractors, part-time or seasonal workers, and those who want more coverage than what’s provided by their group plan.

Insurance is funny, in a weird sort of way, because rates can vary wildly between insurance companies. Also, premiums often change so the insurance provider who offered you the best rate two years ago, or even last year, may not be the insurer who offers you the best car insurance rate today. That’s why it’s so important to shop around, because the quote you get from one company can be significantly higher (or lower) than the quote you get from another.
×